The Ultimate Guide to Custom Keyboard Keycaps: From Basics to Advanced Collecting
• Crestonic DeskLab

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. What Are Keycaps?
  3. The Rise of Custom Keycaps
  4. Keycap Materials: ABS, PBT, and More
  5. Keycap Profiles and Their Impact on Feel
  6. Legend and Printing Methods
    • 6.1 Double-shot Molding
    • 6.2 Dye-Sublimation
    • 6.3 Pad Printing and Laser Etching
  7. Branding, Colorways, and Design Inspiration
  8. Artisan Keycaps: Miniature Sculptures on Your Keyboard
  9. Layout and Sizing Considerations
  10. Group Buys and the Community-Driven Ecosystem
  11. Popular Keycap Brands and Vendors
  12. DIY Keycap Projects and Customization
  13. Caring for and Maintaining Your Keycaps
  14. Notable Market Trends and Future Outlook
  15. Conclusion

1. Introduction

Mechanical keyboards and custom keycaps have exploded in popularity over the past decade, transitioning from an obscure hobby for typists and retro computing enthusiasts to a visible, mainstream subculture. For many, the keyboard once seemed like a strictly utilitarian accessory—just a collection of plastic keys you pressed to type. Yet, in today’s environment, the keyboard can be a canvas for personal expression and an essential tool for comfort, productivity, and aesthetics.

Central to this movement is the concept of custom keycaps. By swapping out stock caps for higher-quality, visually striking, or specially sculpted alternatives, enthusiasts can transform the entire look of their keyboard while also refining typing feel and longevity. The design possibilities are almost endless, from the simplest color swaps to fully themed sets that capture everything from anime inspiration to nature motifs, to specialized keycaps that reflect hobbies, favorite games, or pop culture. This comprehensive guide takes you step-by-step through all the fundamental aspects of keycaps, helping you understand their history, manufacturing processes, keycap profiles, group-buy culture, brand landscape, and more. Whether you’re a newcomer or an advanced collector, this guide is intended to deepen your appreciation of the craft and community around custom keyboard keycaps.

2. What Are Keycaps?

At the most basic level, a keycap is the removable top piece that sits on the mechanical switch of a keyboard. In contrast to cheaper membrane or rubber-dome keyboards—where the key and switch mechanism are often integrated—the mechanical keyboard design allows for easy replacement of these plastic caps. Because you can remove them without damaging the switches or the board, enthusiasts have taken advantage of the flexibility to create myriad designs and materials for keycaps.

Beyond mere aesthetics, keycaps also impact how a keyboard feels in use. If you’ve ever typed on a very cheap plastic set versus a high-quality thick molded set, you’ll notice differences in sound (the tone or “thock”), texture under the fingertips, and even how stable the keys feel. Therefore, selecting the right keycap set isn’t just about the colorway—it’s about hand-feel, geometry, and durability, making the experience as functional as it is visually pleasing.

3. The Rise of Custom Keycaps

While mechanical keyboards date back many decades (think IBM Model M in the 1980s and earlier beam-spring keyboards from the 1970s), the world of custom keycaps gained momentum in the late 2000s. Several factors contributed:

  1. Mechanical Keyboard Revival: Widespread popularity of Cherry MX-style switches for gaming and typing ignited a new wave of enthusiasts.
  2. Community Platforms: Forums like Geekhack, Deskthority, and later Reddit (/r/MechanicalKeyboards) became thriving hubs for sharing knowledge, group buys, and creative designs.
  3. Group Buy Model: Manufacturers and designers realized they could crowdfund new keycap sets by taking community pre-orders, reducing financial risk and enabling limited-edition collaborations.
  4. Artisan Craze: Skilled crafters began hand-sculpting resin keycaps in small batches, catalyzing a whole niche of collectible, artistic “artisan” caps.
  5. Influence of Streaming and YouTube: Mechanical keyboard builds and unboxings found an audience online, further propelling interest in custom sets and one-of-a-kind designs.

By the 2010s, custom keycap sets—often run under brand names like GMK, SP (Signature Plastics), ePBT (EnjoyPBT), and so on—became a hallmark of mechanical keyboard culture. Hand-in-hand with the shift to custom keyboard building (selecting your own PCB, case, plate, switches, etc.), keycaps equally turned into a specialized domain, offering enthusiasts a vast palette for personalization.

4. Keycap Materials: ABS, PBT, and More

Keycaps are generally crafted from specialized plastic resins designed to hold up under constant tapping. The two most widespread materials are:

4.1 ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene)

  • Features:
    • ABS is well-known for its smooth texture and potential to develop a slight “shine” after prolonged use.
    • It’s relatively easy to mold, which is why it’s favored by many manufacturers.
  • Sound Profile:
    • Often described as producing a slightly more hollow or higher-pitched sound than thicker PBT.
    • Thick ABS sets (like GMK sets) can yield a deeper or more “creamy” tone, prized by enthusiasts.
  • Durability:
    • While ABS can wear to a shine on heavily used keys, well-made ABS caps can still last for many years without structural issues.

4.2 PBT (Polybutylene Terephthalate)

  • Features:
    • PBT is denser, more rigid, and has a naturally textured or matte finish that resists shine longer.
    • Typically more resistant to heat distortion and chemicals than ABS.
  • Sound Profile:
    • Often perceived as producing a slightly deeper, more solid “thock”—though thickness and manufacturing quality matter significantly.
  • Durability:
    • PBT rarely develops the polished shine that ABS does, making it a popular choice for those who value a consistent, non-glossy look.

4.3 Other Materials

  • POM (Polyoxymethylene): Offers a smooth surface and strong durability, but less commonly used for full sets. It’s sometimes found in specialized artisan production due to its machinability.
  • Resin or Polyurethane: Often used in unique artisan keycaps, where crafters pour custom molds or sculpt by hand, frequently resulting in translucent or glow-in-the-dark effects.
  • Metal Keycaps: An even smaller niche. Aluminum or brass keycaps exist, although they can significantly alter typing feel and weight distribution.

Selecting the right material is a balance between cost, desired hand-feel, and longevity. Top-tier ABS or PBT sets can be similarly priced; personal preference in texture and sound typically dictates which a user might prefer.

5. Keycap Profiles and Their Impact on Feel

The profile of a keycap refers to its shape and height profile across the rows on a keyboard. This geometry heavily influences typing ergonomics, finger travel, and the overall aesthetic. Some of the most popular profiles include:

  • OEM: Common with many stock keyboards. Slightly taller than Cherry profile, with a noticeable cylindrical top.
  • Cherry: A bit shorter and more sculpted than OEM. Many GMK keycap sets adopt this. Cherry is revered for a comfortable slope and moderate height.
  • SA: Known for its tall, spherical tops. The profile is quite “vintage” looking, reminiscent of terminals from the 1970s. Manufactured by companies like Signature Plastics, SA sets are valued for a deep, resonant typing sound but can fatigue some users due to taller key height.
  • DSA: Uniform, low-profile caps with a gently spherical top. Each row is essentially the same shape, meaning you can rearrange keys easily without worrying about row mismatch.
  • XDA/KDA: Similar in concept to DSA but often slightly larger surface area on top and a bit taller, also uniform across rows.
  • KAT/KAM: More modern uniform profiles with smooth curves or angled shapes, focusing on minimal finger travel and consistent coverage.
  • ASA, MDA, and Others: Numerous custom profiles exist, each with subtle variations in height, top shape, and sculpting from row to row.

Choosing the right profile is subjective. Some users love the old-school heft of SA, while others prefer the lower, gentler slope of Cherry or the flat uniformity of DSA. It’s wise to try different profiles if possible or seek out community feedback before investing in premium sets.

6. Legend and Printing Methods

How legends (the letters, numbers, and symbols) get onto the keytips can dramatically affect durability and clarity. The three most common methods are:

6.1 Double-shot Molding

In double-shot molding, two layers of plastic are injected sequentially. The first layer forms the legend; the second layer forms the rest of the keycap around it.

  • Pros:
    • Legends never fade; they’re physical plastic shapes.
    • Crisp, consistent lettering (assuming good manufacturing).
  • Cons:
    • More expensive to produce.
    • Detailed or very thin fonts can be challenging or impossible to mold well.

GMK sets are a famous example of double-shot ABS, providing consistent, high-quality legends. Many PBT brands also offer double-shot versions in a wide array of fonts and colors.

6.2 Dye-Sublimation

Dye-sublimation involves heating dye so that it infuses directly into the surface of the keycap.

  • Pros:
    • Legends become part of the key surface, highly resistant to wear.
    • Excellent for multi-color or intricate designs, especially with PBT.
  • Cons:
    • Typically done on lighter-colored caps because the dye has to be darker than the base plastic.
    • Small details can sometimes blur if the process is not well-executed.

Many iconic PBT sets, especially those with retro or pastel color motifs, use dye-sub technology.

6.3 Pad Printing and Laser Etching

  • Pad Printing: Involves physically stamping ink onto the keycap, then applying a protective coating. Over time, the legend can wear off. This is common on cheaper sets or mainstream OEM keyboards.
  • Laser Etching: A laser burns away or discolors the top layer of the plastic to form the legend. Frequently combined with backlighting for gaming keyboards. Over time, the legend might become less distinct, or the key surface can degrade.

From a purely enthusiast standpoint, double-shot and dye-sub methods are generally superior in longevity and design quality. However, for certain backlit boards or specialized color combos, pad printing or laser methods can still be practical (often in mass-market, budget-friendly boards).

7. Branding, Colorways, and Design Inspiration

One of the most exciting facets of custom keycaps is the innovation around color palettes and theming. Some sets replicate or draw inspiration from:

  1. Vintage Aesthetics: Beige with gray mods (short for modifier keys), referencing old IBM or Apple color schemes.
  2. Pop Culture: Anime references, gaming themes, or references to iconic color combinations (e.g., “Cyberpunk,” “Metaverse,” etc.).
  3. Nature or Minimalism: Earthy tones, watery gradients, or monochrome sets for a sleek, modern look.
  4. Retro-Futurism: High-contrast neon or “futuristic” styles with stylized legends.

Designers frequently release details called “IC” (Interest Check) posts, featuring mockups of their proposed set. If the community shows enough enthusiasm, the set transitions to a group buy, working with a keycap manufacturer for mass production. This iterative approach fosters creativity, as makers blend personal taste with community feedback to refine color saturations, accent keys, novelty sub-legends, and so forth.

8. Artisan Keycaps: Miniature Sculptures on Your Keyboard

Artisan keycaps are a niche within a niche—each keycap is effectively a tiny piece of art. These are typically single keycaps rather than full sets.

  • Materials: Often resin, but can also involve metal, clay, or gemstones.
  • Themes: Everything from cute cats, surreal skulls, galaxies swirling under a transparent top layer, to comedic pop-culture references.
  • Manufacturing: Some artisans hand-sculpt originals, then create silicone molds to cast small batches. Others 3D-print prototypes, refine them, then hand-paint.
  • Rarity and Collectibility: Because artisans often produce only a few dozen pieces per design, competition for them can be intense. Some artisan caps become highly valuable on second-hand markets.
  • Placement: Often used on the escape key or function keys—some folks build entire artisan-themed keyboards, though that can be quite expensive.

For many collectors, artisanal caps serve as a personal statement or a finishing touch, transforming a standard layout into something uniquely theirs. They blend sculpture, painting, and industrial design into a single key-sized collectible.

9. Layout and Sizing Considerations

When purchasing a custom keycap set, you must consider keyboard layout. Different boards may have:

  • ANSI vs. ISO: Distinct differences around the Enter and Shift keys. ANSI is standard in the US, while ISO is common in Europe.
  • 60%, 65%, TKL, Full-Size: Smaller boards might have fewer or differently sized keys such as a short Right Shift or a combined Backspace/| key.
  • Specialty Layouts: Alice-style boards (split, ergonomic layout), ortholinear boards, or 40% mini boards need quite unusual key sizes.

Manufacturers often sell sets with extra keys (a “base kit” plus “extensions” or “spacebar kits”) to accommodate multiple layouts. Always verify that your chosen set includes the specific row profiles and keycaps your build requires—especially for smaller keyboards or those with specialized bottom rows.

10. Group Buys and the Community-Driven Ecosystem

A hallmark of the custom keycap world is the group buy business model. Rather than stocking thousands of sets in a warehouse, creators launch a pre-order phase during which enthusiasts commit to purchasing. After the buy closes:

  1. Manufacturing: The vendor places an order with the factory (e.g., GMK, EPBT, JTK) based on the final numbers.
  2. Production Lead Times: This can take anywhere from a few months to over a year, depending on factory queues.
  3. Shipping to Participants: Once sets arrive at the vendor, they are packed and shipped to each buyer.

While group buys let communities fund otherwise impractical or low-volume colorways, the waiting game can be both thrilling and frustrating. Delays happen, but the payoff is receiving a unique set that might never be produced again (or not for many years). In recent years, more vendors have started producing “in-stock” sets to reduce wait times, but group buys remain integral to fostering new designs.

11. Popular Keycap Brands and Vendors

Below are a few major players in the custom keycap sphere:

  • GMK: A German manufacturer famous for high-quality ABS double-shot sets. Known for consistent legends, thick walls, and a luxurious typing feel.
  • Signature Plastics (SP): An American company behind iconic profiles such as SA, DSA, and more. SP keycaps are beloved by fans of tall or uniform-profile sets.
  • ePBT (EnjoyPBT): Specializes in dye-sub PBT sets. Typically includes big variety in kits, good color saturation, and slightly more budget-friendly pricing compared to GMK.
  • JTK: Another brand for double-shot ABS sets delivering Cherry-like profiles at somewhat lower cost.
  • Keyreative: Known for KAT/KAM profiles, employs advanced dye-sub processes that enable vibrant legends even on darker caps.
  • Infinikey (by TKC): Offers PBT sets in Cherry profile with Crisp dye-sub legends.
  • Vendors: Global ones like Drop, KBDfans, NovelKeys, Cannon Keys, and MyKeyboard.eu facilitate group buys or stock curated sets.

For artisans, each maker is essentially their own brand—like Jelly Key, Rama Works (which also offers entire keyboards), Hibi, Bro Caps, Sodie Caps, etc. They sometimes collaborate with mainstream vendors for exclusive runs.

12. DIY Keycap Projects and Customization

For those wanting to go even deeper:

  1. Hand-Painting: Some enthusiasts paint designs on blank caps using model paint, then seal them with a protective coating.
  2. Resin Casting: If you’re artistically inclined, you can sculpt or 3D print masters, create silicone molds, and pour colored resins. This is the essence of artisan keycap creation.
  3. Reverse Dye-Sublimation: A small subset of crafters experiment with custom dye-sub setups. By printing their own designs on dye-sublimation transfer paper and carefully applying heat, they create one-of-a-kind patterns or text on PBT.
  4. Laser Engraving: For those with access to a laser cutter/engraver, you can etch designs or text onto blank caps—particularly if the color is suitable for high contrast.

These custom approaches allow for absolute personalization, albeit with a steeper learning curve in tools, materials, and production technique.

13. Caring for and Maintaining Your Keycaps

Just like other aspects of your keyboard, keycaps benefit from consistent upkeep:

  1. Regular Dusting: Use a soft brush or compressed air to clear crumbs and dust between the caps.
  2. Deeper Cleaning: Periodically remove the caps and soak them in warm soapy water, gently scrubbing with a soft cloth to remove oils or grime.
  3. Avoid Harsh Chemicals: Abrasive cleaners or strong solvents can distort plastic or remove dyes, especially from ABS.
  4. Handle with Care: When removing or reinstalling caps, use a proper keycap puller. Avoid prying with metal tools that can crack stems or damage switches.
  5. Watch for UV or Heat Exposure: Extreme sunlight or heat can degrade certain plastics, leading to discoloration or warping.

With proper handling, high-quality keys can remain pristine for many years, especially PBT sets that are more resilient to shining.

14. Notable Market Trends and Future Outlook

The custom keyboard scene has grown exponentially. Some intriguing trends and directions:

  1. In-Stock Availability: More vendors are transitioning popular group-buy colorways into in-stock sets to reduce wait times. This fosters a shift toward immediate gratification.
  2. Eco-friendly Materials: Biodegradable plastics or recycled PBT might emerge as a focus for eco-conscious manufacturers.
  3. Hybrid Processes: Combining double-shot with dye-sublimation or advanced laser layering to create hyper-detailed legends or multi-layer color effects.
  4. Profile Experiments: Each year, new or revived profiles appear—like DMK, or brand-specific forms that merge features from Cherry, DSA, or SA.
  5. Artisan Community Growth: Artisan makers continue pushing boundaries, from complex multi-part resin casts to collaborations with major IPs (intellectual properties) or famous designers.

With the mechanical keyboard hobby inexorably tied to creativity, competition, and constant evolution, it is likely that both mainstream brands and indie designers will keep launching novel approaches to keycaps, fueling the vibrant subculture for years to come.

15. Conclusion

Keycaps might once have been an afterthought—mass-produced plastic lumps that came attached to your keyboard. But in the realm of mechanical keyboard enthusiasts, keycaps have become a canvas for artistic expression, a route to improved typing comfort, and a defining element of personal style. Whether you’re drawn to the minimalistic lines of a uniform-profile PBT set, the nostalgic chunkiness of SA, the meticulously color-matched synergy of a GMK group buy, or the whimsical artistry of a single artisan escape key, there’s a niche for every kind of taste.

Embarking on your own journey into custom keycaps can feel overwhelming at first, especially when you see the broad range of colorways, materials, and shapes on the market. But the variety is part of the joy—there is no “one-size-fits-all.” Each user can find the perfect synergy with their keyboard, environment, and personality. By understanding the differences in materials, manufacturing techniques, profiles, and legends, you’ll be better equipped to select a set that truly speaks to you. And if you eventually find yourself futzing around with custom dyes or launching an interest check for your own design, well…that’s just proof you’ve fully embraced the playful, creative spirit that makes custom keycaps such a beloved hobby.

Whether your ultimate goal is a robust daily driver that withstands your busiest work hours, or a showpiece keyboard that mesmerizes with sculpted artisans, there’s always more to explore. As you search for your next favorite set—visiting community forums, browsing group buys, or engaging with artisan makers—remember that the journey itself is part of what brings mechanical keyboard fans together. So, pick a profile that pleases your fingertips, a colorway that brightens your mornings, and a set of legends that convey your unique flair. Happy typing, and welcome to the endlessly creative world of custom keyboard keycaps!

    Previous Next